​

Insurance Isn’t Just My Career—It’s My Calling

At Nothum Insurance, I believe insurance should be simple, personal, and built around your needs—not the goals of a single insurance company.
 

My name is Spencer Nothum, and I’ve been helping individuals, families, and businesses protect what matters most since becoming licensed in 2015. Over the years, I’ve had the opportunity to see the insurance industry from nearly every angle, and that experience allows me to provide advice that’s focused on what’s best for you.

​

A Journey That Built Experience

I began my insurance career with a large national insurance company, where I learned the fundamentals of personal insurance, customer service, and risk management. It was an excellent foundation, but I quickly realized that representing only one company often meant I couldn’t always recommend the best solution for every client. That realization led me to become an independent insurance agent.
 

Working independently opened my eyes to the value of choice. Instead of trying to make one company’s products fit every situation, I could compare multiple insurance companies and tailor coverage to each client’s unique needs.
 

Later, I joined a respected local independent insurance agency, where I expanded my expertise into commercial insurance and worked with businesses throughout Missouri. During that time, I developed experience protecting manufacturers, contractors, restaurants, nonprofits, retailers, professional offices, farms, and many other types of businesses. Every business faces different risks, and I learned that the best insurance programs are built through conversations—not one-size-fits-all policies.
 

My career then took me into commercial and consumer banking as a loan officer. While banking may seem like a different profession, it gave me an entirely new perspective on financial risk. Working with borrowers, reviewing financial statements, evaluating cash flow, understanding lending requirements, and helping families and businesses make important financial decisions deepened my understanding of how insurance fits into a person’s overall financial picture. I gained valuable insight into protecting assets, managing liabilities, planning for the unexpected, and understanding what lenders look for when financing homes, vehicles, farms, and businesses.
 

That experience reinforced something I had already begun to believe:
 

Insurance is most valuable when it’s part of a bigger financial strategy—not just another monthly bill.

​

Why I Returned to Insurance

After working in both insurance and banking, I knew exactly where I belonged. I came back to insurance because I believe there is a better way to serve people. Too often, insurance feels confusing, rushed, or transactional. Policies are renewed without review, important coverages are overlooked, and customers rarely know whether they’re properly protected. I wanted to build an agency where every client receives honest advice, education, and personalized recommendations—not pressure or sales tactics.

​

Experience That Works for You

Over the past decade, I’ve helped clients with nearly every area of insurance, including:

• Auto Insurance

• Homeowners Insurance

• Renters Insurance

• Condo Insurance

• Landlord Insurance

• Farm Insurance

• Umbrella Insurance

• Life Insurance

• Commercial Property Insurance

• General Liability Insurance

• Commercial Auto Insurance

• Workers’ Compensation

• Professional Liability

• Directors & Officers Liability

• Employment Practices Liability

• Cyber Liability

• Business Owners Policies (BOP)

• Medicare Solutions

​

Whether you’re buying your first home, growing your family, starting a business, or planning for retirement, every stage of life brings new risks—and new opportunities to protect what you’ve worked hard to build.

​

Education Never Stops

Insurance is constantly changing, and staying current matters. I have earned the Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation, one of the insurance industry’s most respected professional credentials. This designation reflects advanced education in personal insurance, commercial insurance, agency operations, risk management, and insurance planning. I also completed the Missouri Bankers Association School of Banking, further strengthening my knowledge of lending, financial analysis, and business operations.
 

This combination of insurance and financial experience allows me to look beyond individual policies and help clients make well-informed decisions about protecting their families, businesses, and financial futures.

​

Independent Means More Choices

As an independent insurance agency, Nothum Insurance isn’t tied to a single insurance company. Instead, I work with multiple trusted insurance carriers to compare coverage options, pricing, and policy features. My goal is simple: find the coverage that best fits your needs and budget while providing the guidance to help you make confident decisions.

​

Local Service You Can Count On

I’m proud to call Washington, Missouri home. As a local business owner, husband, father, and active member of the community, I understand the importance of relationships. My clients aren’t policy numbers—they’re neighbors, friends, business owners, and families I have the privilege of serving. When you call Nothum Insurance, you’ll speak with someone who knows your name, understands your situation, and is committed to being there when you need help.

​

Our Mission

At Nothum Insurance, our mission is simple:
 

To help individuals, families, and businesses protect what they’ve built through honest advice, exceptional service, and insurance solutions tailored to their unique needs.

Because insurance isn’t just about replacing what’s lost. It’s about protecting your future, your livelihood, and the people who matter most.